Research Article |
Corresponding author: Robert J.B. Hoare ( hoarer@landcareresearch.co.nz ) Academic editor: Peter Huemer
© 2019 Brian H. Patrick, Hamish J.H. Patrick, Robert J.B. Hoare.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Patrick BH, Patrick HJH, Hoare RJB (2019) Review of the endemic New Zealand genus Arctesthes Meyrick (Lepidoptera, Geometridae, Larentiinae), with descriptions of two new range-restricted species. Alpine Entomology 3: 121-136. https://doi.org/10.3897/alpento.3.33944
|
The genus Arctesthes Meyrick (Geometridae: Larentiinae: Xanthorhoini), endemic to the South Island of New Zealand, is revised. Four species are recognised, including two new species, as follows: Arctesthes catapyrrha (Butler, 1877), A. siris (Hudson, 1908), A. titanica sp. nov. and A. avatar sp. nov. All except A. catapyrrha are restricted to subalpine and alpine localities. Adults and genitalia are fully described and illustrated for all species; larvae of A. catapyrrha are also briefly described and illustrated. Only Arctesthes catapyrrha is widespread; A. siris is restricted to a few mountain ranges of Central Otago; A. titanica is only known from two wetland localities in the Von Valley of the Otago Lakes district, and A. avatar is only known from a few wetlands in a restricted area of north-west Nelson. The two new species are considered of very high priority for conservation.
New Zealand, Southern Alps, Geometridae, Larentiinae, Xanthorhoini, new species, conservation
New Zealand has a relatively diverse and almost entirely endemic fauna of Geometridae, with Larentiinae by far the best represented subfamily (e.g.,
Ironically, the only species hitherto assigned to the genus Arctesthes in its original description is A. chrysopeda, described by
The two Arctesthes species described here were discovered in 2004 and 2012, and are therefore the first new species of this genus found since the discovery of A. siris in 1906. They are closely related and very similar, but differ from the previously known species in their size and especially in some features of the genitalia, necessitating a broader definition of the genus. Since the two new Arctesthes species are readily identifiable and clearly distinct based on morphological characters, both external and genitalic, we have described them here without presenting data on DNA barcodes. However, molecular work is in progress and barcodes will be added to the Barcode of Life Data System (BOLD) when available.
All four Arctesthes species are confined to open grassland or wetland habitats of the South Island, and only A. catapyrrha has been found in lowland localities (below 600 m), though it is also common in the subalpine and alpine zones.
Genitalia dissection followed standard techniques for Lepidoptera, as described by e.g.
Terminology for wing markings follows
The following acronyms are used for collections where specimens are held:
BLNZ: Brian Lyford private collection, Queenstown, New Zealand
BPNZ: Brian Patrick private collection, Christchurch, New Zealand
Specimens currently in private collections are all destined for eventual deposition in New Zealand museums and research institutions.
Latitude and longitude for type localities was derived from the online gazetteer Topomap NZ (https://www.topomap.co.nz/) and not from GPS readings. We have designated a holotype but only a few paratypes of each new species, as paratypes have no name-bearing status in zoological nomenclature (cf.
BHP keeps a record of all Lepidoptera seen by him in notebooks; numbers of records quoted for each species from these notes relate to the number of separate sightings (one sighting = presence on one date at one locality), i.e. a sighting may be of several or many specimens.
Arctesthes Meyrick, 1885. New Zealand Journal of Science 2: 589. Replacement name for Stratonice Meyrick, 1884 (Transactions and proceedings of the New Zealand Institute 16: 64; unavailable, preoccupied by Stratonice Malmgren, 1867 (Annelida: Polychaeta)). Type species: Fidonia catapyrrha Butler, 1877, by original monotypy.
Arcteuthes Meyrick, 1888. Transactions and proceedings of the New Zealand Institute 20: 47. Incorrect subsequent spelling.
Based on the redescription by
(updated from
Endemic to the South Island of New Zealand.
Adults diurnal. Known larvae (catapyrrha, siris) more or less polyphagous on low herbaceous plants in native and / or modified swards.
Fidonia ? catapyrrha Butler, 1877. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London for 1877: 392, pl. 43 fig. 2.
Arctesthes catapyrrha kaikourensis
Prout, 1939. In Seitz, A., The Macrolepidoptera of the World (Stuttgart) 12: 247. Described as subspecies; synonymised (by implication) by
Fidonia catapyrrha: Lectotype: male (here designated), ‘Type [red-ringed circular label] / N. Zeal. 77.34 / Fidonia catapyrrha Butler Type’ (
Fidonia catapyrrha was described from an unspecified number of specimens, but since
Arcesthes catapyrrha kaikourensis: Lectotype: male (designated by
Differences from A. siris and A. titanica are detailed under those species, below.
Adult male (Figs
Male abdomen and genitalia (Figs
Adult female (Figs
Female genitalia (Fig.
(Fig.
WD, MB, KA, MC, SC, MK, OL, CO, DN, FD, SL
This small geometrid is widespread in open low vegetation in the eastern and central South Island, but also near the West Coast in riverbed vegetation. It is found in coastal turfs (i.e., saltmarsh, dune slacks, and river-mouth habitats) as well as riverbeds, river terraces, saltpans, kettleholes, lake-edge turfs and short tussock grasslands of the interior valleys; it also occurs up to 1920 m on the drier eastern and central South Island mountains in cushionfield, snow banks, wetland and open, often depleted grasslands. It can be locally abundant over cushionfield, bare ground or low herbs and grasses, flying by day low to the ground. It often settles and is easily observed as it sunbathes on bare ground or low vegetation, or feeds on flowers (e.g. Aciphylla aurea (Apiaceae), Gentiana spp. (Gentianaceae)). The species is a survivor and can sometimes be found in quite modified short and open grasslands, some of which are kept short by local management needs, such as at the Saint Clair Golf Course in Dunedin or Waimate Airstrip.
The brightly coloured larvae (Fig.
The adults first appear by mid-September at low altitude sites, and the last records are from early May. Most alpine and high alpine records are between December and March. There appear to be up to three generations per year at lowland and inland montane sites, but perhaps just one at the highest altitudes.
This is a common and widespread species: BHP has made 214 records since 1971 (BHP notebooks, Christchurch). There is considerable variation in the form of the saccus in the male genitalia of A. catapyrrha. While most specimens have a long saccus that is more or less aligned with the genital capsule (Fig.
Lythria siris Hudson, 1908. Transactions and proceedings of the New Zealand Institute 40: 106.
Lectotype: male (designated by
Arctesthes siris is similar to A. catapyrrha, but on average smaller. It is easily distinguished by the proximal line of the forewing, which has a distinct concave curve below the middle of the wing; the proximal line in A. catapyrrha is convex (bowed away from the wing base). The hindwing pattern also differs strongly from that of catapyrrha: in siris, the orange coloration is only present as rather narrow V-shaped band beyond the basal blotch and as scattered scales elsewhere; in catapyrrha, orange is the dominant hindwing colour. The dark antemedian line that borders the hindwing basal blotch is much more strongly V-shaped than in catapyrrha.
Arctesthes spp., uppersides. 7) A. siris, male, Zero Gully, Waikaia River CO; 8) A. siris, female, Rock and Pillar Range CO; 9) A. titanica, male paratype, White Burn, Von River OL; 10) A. titanica, female paratype, White Burn, Von River OL; 11) A. titanica, female, Von River north branch OL. Scale bars: 10 mm.
Adult male (Figs
Male abdomen and genitalia (Figs
Adult female (Fig.
Female genitalia (Fig.
(Fig.
CO.
Confined to mountains, where it lives in cushion wetlands and snowbanks. The adults fly by day low over the open vegetation and are found between early December and mid April; they can be locally common in these habitats. Larvae have not been described but have been observed to feed on various low-growing plants including Plantago and Coprosma (BHP, pers. obs.); unfortunately no photographs are available.
This local Central Otago endemic was discovered by railwayman J.H. Lewis in February 1906, high (over 1320 m) on the Old Man Range. BHP has recorded it 37 times since 1982 from seven discrete alpine areas (see Distribution above). In low alpine habitats of Central Otago, both Arctesthes catapyrrha and A. siris can sometimes be found flying together in cushion wetlands, such as at 1400 m on Symes Road on the Old Man Range [45°20.5'S, 169°13.7'E].
Holotype: male (pinned), ‘NZ OL 800m White Burn Sth Br Von R 4 Feb 2006 B M Lyford /
3 males, 3 females, same locality as holotype, 6 Mar 2004, B. & H. Patrick; 4 females, same data as holotype but not dissected; 1 female, OL: North Branch of Von River, 18 Feb 2006, B.M. Lyford; 3 females, North Branch of Von River, 17–18 Feb 2007, B.H. Patrick (Fig.
This species can easily be distinguished from A. catapyrrha by its larger size (in spite of the slight overlap in wingspan measurements, this is always a much more robust, larger-winged moth) and the almost unmarked hindwing upperside. The strongly 3-lobed antemedian line on the hindwing underside is also diagnostic. Differences from A. avatar are given under that species, below.
Adult male (Figs
Arctesthes spp. 12) A. avatar, male paratype upperside, Denniston Plateau NN; 13) A. avatar, female upperside, Denniston Plateau NN; 14) A. catapyrrha, male underside, Yaldhurst MC; 15) A. siris, male underside, Zero Gully CO; 16) A. titanica, male paratype underside, White Burn OL; 17) A. avatar, male underside, Denniston Plateau NN. Scale bars: 10 mm.
Male abdomen and genitalia (Figs
Adult female (Figs
Female genitalia (Fig.
(Fig.
OL.
The species is only known from intermontane wetlands. Both the north and south branches of the Von River harbour rather extensive valley floor wetlands that are a mixture of cushion and moss bogs at 800–820m, surrounded by short tussock or copper tussock (Chionochloa rubra subsp. cuprea) grasslands; individual wetlands are approximately 0.1–0.4 ha in extent. The cushion plant Oreobolus pectinatus is the dominant cushion species, but a wide range of grasses, herbs and sedges share this habitat. Adult moths have been found on four occasions between 4 February and 6 March, but as they were relatively numerous each time and in good condition, their flight period probably extends from late January to late March at least. Adult females laid yellow eggs on leaves which hatched 13 days later. Larvae were given a variety of exotic and native herbs to feed on of which Plantago, prostrate-growing Coprosma, Ranunculus, Bellis and Trifolium were eaten; however, rearing was unsuccessful. The first instar larvae are brown-grey in colour and quite active. Unfortunately, no photographs were taken of the larvae.
Based on its large wingspan compared to A. siris and A. catapyrrha, the species is named (with an element of hyperbole) after the Titans of Greek mythology, primeval deities of enormous size and strength, and by extension after the legendary but ill-fated ‘Titanic’, in its time the largest passenger ship ever built and the subject of the popular James Cameron movie of 1997 (see also Etymology under A. avatar below). The name is a Latin adjective.
Given the narrow distribution of this species and the fragility of its wetland habitat in an area still managed for extensive pastoralism, this species is threatened with extinction. Although the moth is relatively abundant where it occurs, the habitat is small and vulnerable to damage from farming practices such as over-sowing, grazing, stock trampling and vehicle damage. Additionally the areas are mostly unfenced, so recreational vehicles have access to these wetlands and could easily inflict damage as has occurred elsewhere in Otago and Southland.
Holotype: male (pinned), ‘NEW ZEALAND NN Denniston - Rochfort wetland area 855m 16–18 Feb 2015 Brian Patrick /
1 male, same data as holotype; 2 males, 1 female (Fig.
Arctesthes avatar is superficially similar to A. titanica. However, the species are almost certainly strongly allopatric and should be identifiable based on locality alone. The most conspicuous diagnostic characters are on the hindwing upperside and underside as follows: A. avatar has a very distinct wedge-shaped area of dark shading on the hindwing upperside from the base, enclosed by the strongly developed dorsal half of the antemedian line: in A. titanica, the antemedian line is reduced to a smudge on the anal margin only. Arctesthes avatar also has a strong dark terminal shade on the hindwing but lacks black dashes along the termen itself; in A. titanica the black dashes are present and distinct, but there is no terminal shading. The hindwing underside in A. avatar is predominantly very pale orange with only the antemedian line and terminal shading showing up conspicuously darker; in A. titanica, the hindwing underside is predominantly mid-brown with the area beyond the antemedian line and the subterminal line showing up conspicuously paler. In the male genitalia, the longer, narrower labides and much shorter sacculus process easily distinguish A. avatar from A. titanica.
Adult male (Figs
Male genitalia (Figs
Adult female (Figs
Female genitalia (Fig.
(Fig.
NN.
The species has been found at 640–1000 m a.s.l. in ephemeral wetlands of short sedges and herbs, including Liparophyllum, Donatia, Ficinia, Oreobolus and Euphrasia species. Specimens have been disturbed or taken flying by day from 6 February to 22 March. Females were observed to lay eggs in rows on the underside of leaves of Liparophyllum gunnii (Menyanthaceae) growing in the wettest areas. A larva reared from the egg in captivity was briefly described as brown dorsally, paler ventrally, and fed on dying leaves, stems and roots of Liparophyllum, but rearing was unsuccessful and it was not photographed. In a 2015 survey, BHP and Ian Millar found that Liparophyllum was the only dicot herb present at all sites where the moth was found, so, unlike other Arctesthes species, A. avatar may be monophagous on this plant.
Forest & Bird, who organised the Denniston Plateau BioBlitz at which this species was found, ran a public competition to choose a name for this species. The ‘avatar moth’ was picked as the winning entry. The name refers to the James Cameron movie Avatar; like the indigenous people and fauna of that film, the moth is vulnerable to habitat change or destruction in its very limited area of occurrence. The original avatars of Hindu mythology were incarnations of deities, especially of Vishnu: one of these, Varaha the boar, is depicted in a Pahari miniature painting of ca 1740 with the black, white and orange coloration of A. avatar killing a demon and rescuing the Earth on his tusks (image available from Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chamba,_Himachal_Pradesh). The name is to be treated as a noun in apposition.
The discovery of this species in 2012 was briefly discussed by
We have described the two new Arctesthes species here to promote their future monitoring and conservation, and to highlight the need for continued Lepidoptera survey work in the New Zealand alpine zone. Quantitative studies as well as work on life histories and ecology are particularly needed. Already one formerly common endemic geometrid species, Xanthorhoe bulbulata (Guenée, 1868), has declined drastically and is feared possibly extinct (
We are grateful to Eric Edwards, Department of Conservation, Invercargill, for showing BHP the collections of insects from the Von Valley that contained Arctesthes titanica in a timely manner, enabling an expedition to the site while the adults were still flying. We thank Forest and Bird for organising the BioBlitz on the Denniston Plateau in March 2012 that led to a further new species of Arctesthes being discovered. Additionally we acknowledge the skill and patience of Birgit Rhode of Manaaki Whenua—Landcare Research, Auckland, in taking and editing the colour photographs of set adult moths and structural features and putting together the plates. We sincerely thank Axel Hausmann and Pasi Sihvonen for their helpful reviews of this manuscript. This work was funded in part by Core funding for Crown Research Institutes from the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment’s Science and Innovation group.