Research Article |
Corresponding author: Christoph Germann ( germann.christoph@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Yannick Chittaro
© 2023 Christoph Germann, Michael Geiser, Matthias Borer.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Germann C, Geiser M, Borer M (2023) A review of the Chrysolina species – subgenus Stichoptera Motschulsky, 1860 – in Switzerland, with notes on distribution, conservation and preimaginal stages (Coleoptera, Chrysomelidae). Alpine Entomology 7: 69-82. https://doi.org/10.3897/alpento.7.105937
|
The species of the subgenus Stichoptera occurring in Switzerland are revised, based on a combination of literature data, old museum specimens and recent material. Four species, one with two subspecies, Chrysolina kuesteri (Helliesen, 1912), Ch. latecincta latecincta (Demaison, 1896), Ch. latecincta norica (Holdhaus, 1914), Ch. rossia (Illiger, 1802) and Ch. sanguinolenta (Linnaeus, 1758) are confirmed to occur in Switzerland, while Ch. gypsophilae (Küster, 1845) has to be excluded from the Swiss fauna due to insufficient evidence. Errors and unclarities in the older literature are discussed. Ch. kuesteri was found abundantly in central Valais, allowing some notes on its larval biology. Larvae of the alpine Ch. latecincta are also illustrated, along with notes on its habitat and some past and present distribution records. Illustrations for all Swiss members of the subgenus, as well as distribution maps with all confirmed records, are provided.
Die Arten der Untergattung Stichoptera, welche in der Schweiz vorkommen, wurden auf der Grundlage einer Kombination von Literaturdaten, alten Museumsbelegen und aktuellen Funden revidiert. Vier Arten, dabei eine mit zwei Unterarten, Chrysolina kuesteri (Helliesen, 1912), Ch. latecincta latecincta (Demaison, 1896), Ch. latecincta norica (Holdhaus, 1914), Ch. rossia (Illiger, 1802) und Ch. sanguinolenta (Linnaeus, 1758) werden als in der Schweiz vorkommend bestätigt, während Ch. gypsophilae (Küster, 1845) ohne bestätigende Belege ausgeschlossen werden muss. Fehler und Unklarheiten in historischer Literatur werden diskutiert. Ch. kuesteri wurde häufig im Zentralwallis gefunden, was zu Beobachtungen über die Larvalbiologie führte. Larven der alpin verbreiteten Ch. latecincta werden auch abgebildet, zusammen mit Bemerkungen über das Habitat und historischen sowie rezenten Verbreitungsdaten. Abbildungen für alle schweizerischen Arten des Subgenus, sowie Fundortkarten aller überprüften Funde werden gegeben.
Chrysomelinae, biology, larvae, faunistics, Switzerland
Leaf beetles (Chrysomelidae) are the third most diverse beetle family in Switzerland and worldwide (
At present, 38 species and subspecies of the genus Chrysolina are recorded from Switzerland (unpublished data), five of which in the subgenus Stichoptera Motschulsky, 1860: Ch. gypsophilae (Küster, 1845), Ch. kuesteri (Helliesen, 1912), Ch. latecincta (Demaison, 1896), Ch. rossia (Illiger, 1802) and Ch. sanguinolenta (Linnaeus, 1758). In total, this subgenus contains fifteen valid species and numerous subspecies (
The central European members of Stichoptera form a rather difficult species complex, hence Chrysolina species with a red coloured margin of the elytra were often confused or misinterpreted in the literature. The 19th century literature cites the species names Ch. marginalis Duftschmid, 1825 and Ch. sanguinolenta (Linnaeus, 1758) as separate species, even though they are now considered synonyms (
The present study aims at summarising the current state of knowledge on all members of the subgenus Stichoptera in Switzerland, as far as reliable specimens were available, in order to paint a clearer picture of their distribution within the country. We also provide additional data on newly discovered populations of Ch. kuesteri in central Valais and details on the larval biology of this species, alongside some notes on the larvae of the alpine Ch. latecincta latecincta.
The initial idea for this study came after Chrysolina kuesteri, a species only recently published as new to the Swiss fauna (
We then revised all specimens of Stichoptera from Switzerland and immediately adjacent areas contained within the following collections:
AGRO – Agroscope-Changins, Nyon.
Pairs of live Ch. kuesteri from Mont d’Orge (Sion, Valais) and Ch. latecincta from Griespass (Ulrichen, Valais) were kept in multiuse plastic boxes (see
a–g. Dorsal habitus of males of Chrysolina (Stichoptera) from Switzerland. a, c. Ch. kuesteri, Raron VS; b, d. Ch. sanguinolenta, Scuol GR; e. Ch. latecincta latecincta Griespass VS; f. Ch. latecincta norica Fusio TI. Arrows indicate relevant differences; pronotum more shiny and glabrous in Ch. sanguinolenta (d), antennal segments shorter and thicker in Ch. latecincta (e, f), shape of pronotum trapezoid and circular elytra in Ch. rossia (g) (Photos: M. Borer, C. Germann).
Based on the above treatments, we are not able to determine which species these early authors had at hand, considering that Ch. marginalis is treated as synonymous with Ch. sanguinolenta in the current literature (
Records given by
Four species and one additional subspecies of Stichoptera are here confirmed to occur in Switzerland. All registered specimens and records (Suppl. material
Localities of all revised specimens of the subgenus Stichoptera from Switzerland, before the year 2000 (above), and after (below). Colour code: green Ch. kuesteri, red Ch. sanguinolenta, dark blue Ch. latecincta norica, light blue Ch. latecincta latecincta, yellow Ch. rossia (Background map: swisstopo.ch).
In the following we provide data for all species, including habitus photos (Fig.
This species occurs in large parts of Europe, particularly in the South, as well as in the Near East, Caucasus and Central Asia (
1 ♀: «Coll. Ch. Maerky Grammont» [Le Grammont, VS?] (
This species is widespread in Europe.
1 ♂, 2 ♀: St. Gallen, ex coll. Täschler [without date] (NMSG). 1 ♂, 1 ♀: Basel coll. Burghold [without date] (
(2000 onwards). 1 ♀: VS, Kalpetran, 3.6.2000, ex. coll. G. Carron (cYC). 1♀: Helv, VS, Leuk, 615/129, PR2, 26.V.2001, leg. C. Monnerat, det. M. Borer, 2017 (cCM). 1 ex. VS, Sierre, Route Sion 46, 606.247, 126.219, 23.10.2012 (cYC), 1 ♀: VS, St. Léonard, 599, 122, 13.5.2013, leg. R. Graf (cRG). 2 ex.: Hell 662 m, CH-VS-Salgesch, 610787, 129327, 9.xi.[20]14, leg. and det. L. Lischer (cCG). 1 ex.: Marjunne, 709 m, CH, VS, Varen, 613582, 129671, 9.vi.[20]14, leg. and det. L. Lischer (cCG). 1 ♂: Helv, VS, Visperterminen, 634730/122500, 1098 m, 11.V.2017, leg. Y. Chittaro, det. M. Borer 2019 (cYC). 1 ♀: Helv, VS, Varen, 612270-129590, 791 m, 28.V.2017, leg. C. Monnerat, det. M. Borer, 2019 (cCM). 1 ♀: Helv, GE, La Touvière, 488042/114263, 348 m, 24.V.2018, leg. Y. Chittaro, det. M. Borer 2019 (cYC). 1 ♀: Helv, VS, Flanthey, 601540/125155, 952 m, 14.V.2019, leg. Y. Chittaro det. M. Borer 2020 (cYC). 1 ♀: Helv, VS, Brentjong, 616030/129985, 962 m, 31.V.2019, leg. Y. Chittaro, det. M. Borer 2020 (cYC). 1 ♀: Sion, Bisse de Clavau, cours d’eau, vigne [46.25000 / 7.39000], 30.05.2019, leg. S. Breitenmoser (cSB). 1 ♀: Sion, Bisse de Clavau, vigne bosquet [46.25000 / 7.39000], 30.05.2019, leg. S. Breitenmoser (cSB). 1 ex. VS, Conthey, près du Torrent 47, 510 m, 2.II.2020, leg. M. C. Chittaro (cYC). 1 ex. VS, Conthey, près du Torrent 47, 510 m, 27.10.2020, leg. M. C. Chittaro (cYC). 13 ex. VS, Pt. de la Morge, Route de Vuisse, 523 m, 22.4.2020, coll. A. Schmidt (cYC). 1 ♀: Helv, VS, Mayentset, 589812/125364, 1510 m, 22.V.2020, leg. Y. Chittaro, det. M. Borer 2021 (cYC). 1 ♂: CH, VS, Leuk, Erschmatt (Bl), 619.250, 129.925, 1210 m, 13.10.2020, leg. H. Blöchlinger (cHB). 1 ♂: CH, VS, Fully, Les Follatères, 30.9.2020, leg. C. Germann. 1 ♂, 1♀: Sion, Mont d’Orge, 660 m, 592380, 120130 (46°13'58"N, 7°20'24"E), 9.x.2020, leg. A. Geiser-Barkhausen and U. Lemmenmeier (
Based on our own investigations in Valais, plus the data provided to us by colleagues, Ch. kuesteri is locally common around Sion and Leuk. Several previously unknown localised populations were found between in late 2020 and 2021. For a precise map see Fig.
Six couples of Ch. kuesteri from Mont d`Orge (=Montorge Sion, Valais) collected in October 2020 were kept in plastic boxes. As its local host plant in Valais was not exactly determined (but presumed to be Linaria sp.), both adults and larvae were fed on Linaria purpurea, a readily available garden plant. Oviposition was observed on L. purpurea from November until January. In early February 2021 the first larvae were noticed (Fig.
a–g. Preimaginal stages of Chrysolina kuesteri. a. Eggs shortly before hatching, late January; b. First larval instar; c. Larva after first moult in middle of February; d. Larva after fourth moult mid-March; e. Fifth (and last) larval instar, April; f, g. Pupa, lateral and ventral view; h. Freshly hatched adult, end of May (Photos: C. Germann).
Some insights into the development of Ch. kuesteri were already provided by
Based on the recent revision by
1 ex. [VS] Binn, Eggerhorn, 2400 m, 6.8.[19]46, leg. and coll. E. Handschin (
15 adults from Griespass (Ulrichen, Valais) were kept alive in couples in the same multiuse boxes (
a-f. Preimaginal stages of Chrysolina latecincta latecincta from Griespass. a. Egg; b. Freshly hatched larva; c. First instar larval; d. Third instar Larva; e. Freshly moulted larva after 3rd moult; f. Fourth instar larva in February; g. Fifth (Last) larval instar; h. Pupa (Photos: C. Germann).
1 ♀: Fusio // Campolungo Fusio 21.7.[19]10 // COF06499 coll. Fontana (MCSN). 2 ♂: Fusio // Campolungo Fusio II.7.[19]12 // Chrysomela sanguinolenta // COF06497 coll. Fontana (MCSN). 3 ♂, 4 ♀: Fusio, Ticino, G. C. C. // G. C. Champion Coll. M.B. 1927-409 (
One of us (MG) revisited the area around Bergalga (Avers) on two occasions, in September 2012 and August 2017. Despite two days of intensive searching, no Ch. latecincta were found. Further literature records are adopted from
A remarkable locality of Ch. latecincta norica is Passo Campolungo near Fusio (Ticino), separated from the nearest known populations by some 70 km and several mountain ranges. A single female specimen from this locality was discussed in
A species primarily distributed in the Balkan Peninsula and Italy but reaching also France and Central Europe.
1 ex. TI, Lugano [without date nor collector] (
As this species is recognisable even on photographs, recent « citizen science » data are usually trustworthy. iNaturalist (https://www.inaturalist.org/, accessed 1th February 2023) provide supplementary observations (without voucher specimen) from Chiasso (30th April 2015, 27th April 2020), Brissago (19th October 2016), Giumaglio (24th December 2020) and Aquila (30th May 2022).
Arguably the most widespread species of the subgenus, found across the Palaearctic Region from Great Britain to eastern Siberia and Mongolia, but absent from the Iberian Peninsula (
1 ex. Genève, Veyrier, 7.VI. [without year] coll. Maerky (
Even though this species seems to have been once common and widely distributed in Switzerland, our survey of the available data paints a rather alarming picture. The most recent records of this species in Switzerland date back to the early 1970ies! Given the amount of collecting activity in many of its former localities in recent decades, its sudden decline cannot be entirely attributed to a lack of sampling.
The larvae of this species are notable for being pale brownish in colour (Fig.
In September 2022, an attempt was made to find specimens of Ch. sanguinolenta in vineyards around Begnins (Vaud), where it was last observed, but unfortunately without success.
Our revision of specimens in various museums and private collections often revealed a colourful mixture of species standing under the same name in the collection. We found specimens of Ch. kuesteri, Ch. rossia, as well as occasionally Ch. latecincta, and even Ch. limbata (Fabricius, 1775), a member of the subgenus Zeugotaenia Motschulsky, 1860, all standing as Ch. sanguinolenta or Ch. marginalis! A thorough revision of the determinations often including extraction of the male genitalia proved to be paramount for gathering faunistic data. We therefore advise biological recorders and conservationists working on similarly complicated taxa to refrain from uncritically downloading data from online databases, even if those originate from a museum collection, unless these data are clearly shown to be recently verified by a specialist.
A browse through the «citizen science» data of Stichoptera currently available on iNaturalist (https://www.inaturalist.org/, accessed 4th January 2023) also revealed numerous misidentifications, including some labelled as «research grade».
Due to the historical confusion of Ch. sanguinolenta with its relatives, we were not able to use a large part of the data in the published literature, unless backed up by voucher specimens. The only literature records we were able to accept directly are those contained within
From a conservation point of view, our current state of knowledge is too poor to evaluate the Swiss Stichoptera taxa using IUCN criteria. However, we can make some tentative statements about the conservation status of the taxa in Switzerland: Ch. kuesteri is much more abundant than previously known, particularly in Valais, with many recent records. It appears to be the least threatened of all the Swiss taxa. Our recent field observations of Ch. kuesteri in Valais (Mont d’Orge), may help to shed some light on the ecology of this species. Most of the beetles were observed within the vineyards, smaller numbers at southern exposed sites in the rocky step towards the peak of Mont d’Orge. Around Leuk, our targeted search also revealed a large abundance in a similar habitat. It is notable that Valais is a particularly well sampled area for Coleoptera, and yet most collections made during the past decades did not contain any Ch. kuesteri. Of the 86 voucher specimens we examined, only 21 were collected before 2000, over a range of 120 years, but 65 were collected since 2000. We therefore assume that this species has markedly increased in abundance during the last 20 or so years.
Ch. latecincta latecincta is a high-altitude species potentially threatened by anthropogenic climate change in the long term. However, no drastic population decline was apparent based on our data. Ch. latecincta norica seems to have habits similar to the nominotypical subspecies, but with more widely scattered populations. Our failure to find recent specimens of this species in two well-known localities so far may point to a population decline. A potential threat is climate change and associated greening (
Ch. rossia is restricted to Ticino, but its populations appear to be stable and not in decline, with a fair number of recent observations.
Ch. sanguinolenta, despite being locally common at least in some regions until the 1970ies, has not been recorded from Switzerland for 50 years and must be feared extinct! It turned out to be a particular problem that many records of Ch. kuesteri and occasionally other species were misidentified as this species, obscuring its recent decline. Targeted surveys are now urgently needed, to find surviving populations. Furthermore, the causes of this species’ decline need to be better understood.
Our rearing experiments for Ch. kuesteri and Ch. latecincta confirm a remarkable plasticity in the developmental time for both species. We also confirm a certain oligophagy, already postulated in the relevant literature, for Ch. kuesteri, which readily accepts two different species of Linaria, even though the host plant of this particular population in the field seems to be Veronica. For Ch. latecincta we confirm that other species than Linaria alpina are accepted (both genera are part of the Plantaginaceae, but in different tribes). Hence, we assume that both species may handle uncomfortable environmental conditions and/or loss of host plants to a certain degree. A regular development in winter can be confirmed for Ch. kuesteri. Ch. latecincta latecincta may also develop in winter, depending on the altitude and population. A larval development from spring to summer is likely to be the rule for the population on Griespass (2400 m), where a thick snow cover remains until early summer, greatly slowing down plant growth.
We cordially acknowledge our colleagues Hannes Baur (
Label data, interpreted coordinates and collection references
Data type: collection data of all Chrysolina (Stichoptera) species investigated.
Explanation note: Label data, interpreted coordinates and collection references of all investigated specimens of the following species are given: Chrysolina kuesteri (Helliesen, 1912), Ch. latecincta latecincta (Demaison, 1896), Ch. latecincta norica (Holdhaus, 1914), Ch. rossia (Illiger, 1802) und Ch. sanguinolenta. These data are the basis for the maps provided (Fig.