Research Article |
Corresponding author: Andreas Sanchez ( andreas.sanchez@infofauna.ch ) Academic editor: Stève Breitenmoser
© 2023 Andreas Sanchez, Yannick Chittaro, David Frey, Bärbel Koch, Doris Hölling, Eckehard G. Brockerhoff, Beat Ruffner, Miloš Knížek.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Sanchez A, Chittaro Y, Frey D, Koch B, Hölling D, Brockerhoff EG, Ruffner B, Knizek M (2023) Three alien bark and ambrosia beetles (Coleoptera, Curculionidae, Scolytinae) new to Switzerland. Alpine Entomology 7: 45-55. https://doi.org/10.3897/alpento.7.103269
|
Identifying alien species is important to ensure the early detection of biological invasions and survey shifts in species distributions in the context of global change. Here, we report on three alien bark and ambrosia beetles newly detected in Switzerland: Cyclorhipidion distinguendum (Eggers, 1930), C. pelliculosum (Eichhoff, 1878), and Hypothenemus eruditus (Westwood, 1834). These species were recorded for the first time during a comprehensive survey of saproxylic beetles accross major forest types and along an altitudinal gradient during the entire growing season in the southern Alps, in the canton of Ticino. Their local abundance and number of occurrences accross different lowland forest habitats, including alluvial forests of national importance, indicates that all three species are already naturalized. Given their polyphagy, it is likely that all three species will become more extensively distributed across Switzerland, with a yet unknown environmental impact.
Alien species, biological invasions, distribution, first record, faunistics, introduction, Cyclorhipidion, Hypothenemus
The distributions of organisms are changing at fast rates worldwide (e.g.,
Wood-boring insects are among the invasive species with the greatest ecological and economic impacts (
Xyleborine ambrosia beetles (Coleoptera, Curculionidae, Scolytinae) are species depending on the presence of symbiotic fungi in the larval galleries of their host plants for larval and adult nutrition. The fungi are carried by adults females via their spores in adapted organs, the mycangia, and deposited in the larval galleries of their new hosts (
In Switzerland, Scolytinae are represented by 112 species according to the recent checklist of
Here, we report on three new alien bark and ambrosia beetles species in Switzerland: the two xyleborine ambrosia beetles Cyclorhipidion distinguendum (Eggers, 1930), C. pelliculosum (Eichhoff, 1878), and Hypothenemus eruditus (Westwood, 1834). They were recorded for the first time in 2022 during a comprehensive survey of saproxylic beetles in all major forest typologies and along an altitudinal gradient in the southern Alps, in the canton of Ticino. We discuss the introduction mode, naturalization status, and invasion potential of each species.
Saproxylic beetles were sampled at 57 forest sites (study plots) along an altitudinal gradient (195–1,971 m a.s.l.) in the canton of Ticino in the southern Alps, Switzerland, with 114 unbaited PolytrapTM interception traps (
Voucher specimens are deposited at the Museo cantonale di storia naturale (
All specimens were identified morphologically by A. Sanchez and M. Knížek. The identification of Cyclorhipidion species was based on criteria provided by
To place our Swiss observations within a European context, we considered the distributions proposed by
Among the more than 28,000 beetles trapped in 2022, 366 specimens were found to belong to three ambrosia and bark beetle species recorded for the first time in Switzerland: 187 females of C. distinguendum, 142 females of C. pelliculosum, and 37 specimens of H. eruditus. The details of the recorded specimens are shown below. If not specified otherwise, the collector (leg.) was the project coordinator D. Frey.
Cyclorhipidion distinguendum (Eggers, 1930)
Figs
Switzerland • 1 ♀; Arbedo-Castione, El Gag; 2724273, 1119188 (46.212669245, 9.049077111); 328 m a.s.l.; 10 Apr.–2 May 2022; MCSN. • 2 ♀; Bellinzona, Ruderi del Castello di Claro; 2722751, 1124011 (46.256325540, 9.030627382); 437 m a.s.l.; 14 Jun.–14 Aug. 2022; MCSN. • 49 ♀; Capriasca, Solorónch; 2717643, 1101393 (46.053814854, 8.958714310); 620 m a.s.l.; 2717651, 1101409 (46.053957360, 8.958821658); 626 m a.s.l.; 31 Mar.–5 Sep. 2022; Sanchez A., Knížek M. coll. and MCSN. • 2 ♀; Cadenazzo; Ciossa Antognini; 2714516, 1113409 (46.162423843, 8.921253831); 201 m a.s.l.; 14 Mar.–14 Apr.; MCSN. • 1 ♀; Castel San Pietro, Al Ronco; 2721737, 1080586 (45.865958663, 9.006227205); 510 m a.s.l.; 3–17 May 2022; MCSN. • 1 ♀; Cevio, Ospedale; 2689580, 1130931 (46.323805242, 8.601830413); 426 m a.s.l.; 11–26 Apr. 2022; MCSN. • 13 ♀; Collina d’Oro, Al Lago di Muzzano; 2715093, 1094661 (45.993707761, 8.924126664); 339 m a.s.l.; 2715063, 1094662 (45.993721864, 8.923739798); 339 m a.s.l.; 31 Mar.–12 Aug. 2022; Sanchez A. coll. and MCSN. • 1 ♀; Locarno, Bolette; 2709941, 1112476 (46.154794646, 8.861816697); 195 m a.s.l.; 14–26 Jul. 2022; MCSN. • 11 ♀; Lugano, Ponte Curtina; 2722793, 1104469 (46.080562140, 9.026044051); 676 m a.s.l.; 2722772, 1104459 (46.080476025, 9.025770034); 676 m a.s.l.; 2 May–5 Sep. 2022; Sanchez A. coll. and MCSN. • 7 ♀; Mendrisio, Monte Cristo; 2718662, 1081690 (45.876433372, 8.966918208); 425 m a.s.l.; 2718653, 1081707 (45.876587841, 8.966806589); 438 m a.s.l.; 10 Mar.–17 May 2022; Knížek M. coll. and MCSN. • 2 ♀; Novazzano, In Gall; 2719654, 1078647 (45.848891375, 8.978921620); 293 m a.s.l.; 1 Jun.–12 Jul. 2022; MCSN. • 31 ♀; Novazzano, La Valéta; 2718486, 1077592 (45.839608442, 8.963626081); 445 m a.s.l.; 2718533, 1077578 (45.839474311, 8.964227340); 450 m a.s.l.; 31 Mar.–12 Jul. 2022; MCSN and WSL. • 62 ♀; Vezia, S. Martino; 2716328/1098298 (46.026206809, 8.940961559); 431 m a.s.l.; 2716354, 1098287 (46.026103397, 8.941294533); 414 m a.s.l.; 31 Mar.–3 Oct. 2022; Knížek M. coll., MCSN and WSL.
Actual known distribution of Cyclorhipidion distinguendum in A. Europe (the colonized countries are indicated in blue, and the red dots represent the exact locations of observations) and B. Ticino (Switzerland). (Vector and raster map data swisstopo.ch, naturalearthdata.com).
The morphological identification of C. distinguendum was confirmed by the genetic analysis of two specimens (the sequences were deposited on GenBank: accession numbers OQ872230 and OQ872233). A sequence comparison of the COI-Barcode region of 650 and 589 bp to accessions on the nucleotide database of the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) confirmed the two sequenced specimens as C. distinguendum. Both sequences displayed a 100% similarity with a voucher specimen sequence of C. distinguendum (accession number: MN183038.1).
Cyclorhipidion pelliculosum (Eichhoff, 1878)
Figs
Switzerland • 1 ♀; Capriasca, Solorónch; 2717643, 1101393 (46.053814854, 8.958714310); 620 m a.s.l.; 14 Apr.–2 May 2022; MCSN. • 12 ♀; Castel San Pietro, Al Ronco; 2721737, 1080586 (45.865958663, 9.006227205); 510 m a.s.l.; 25 Apr.–1 Jun. 2022; MCSN and WSL. • 3 ♀; Collina d’Oro, Al Lago di Muzzano; 2715093, 1094661 (45.993707761, 8.924126664); 339 m a.s.l.; 10 Mar.–14 Apr. 2022; Sanchez A. coll. and MCSN. • 1 ♀; Gambarogno, Quinta; 2703119, 1107291 (46.109238055, 8.772383402); 311 m a.s.l.; 11 Apr.–2 May 2022; MCSN. • 14 ♀; Mendrisio, Monte Cristo; 2718662, 1081690 (45.876433372, 8.966918208); 425 m a.s.l.; 2718653, 1081707 (45.876587841, 8.966806589); 438 m a.s.l.; 31 Mar.–17 May 2022; Knížek M. coll., MCSN and WSL. • 13 ♀; Novazzano, In Gall; 2719654, 1078647 (45.848891375, 8.978921620); 293 m a.s.l.; 2719618, 1078694 (45.849320430, 8.978470196); 291 m a.s.l.; 11 Mar.–25 Apr. 2022; MCSN. • 86 ♀; Novazzano, La Valéta; 2718533, 1077578 (45.839474311, 8.964227340); 450 m a.s.l.; 2718486, 1077592 (45.839608442, 8.963626081); 445 m a.s.l.; 10 Mar.–1 Jun. 2022; Sanchez A., Knížek M. coll. and MCSN. • 8 ♀; Stabio, Colombera; 2717648, 1078757 (45.850232009, 8.953132727); 345 m a.s.l.; 31 Mar.–17 May 2022; MCSN. • 4 ♀; Vezia, S. Martino; 2716354, 1098287 (46.026103397, 8.941294533); 414 m a.s.l.; 31 Mar.–2 May 2022; MCSN.
Actual known distribution of Cyclorhipidion pelliculosum in A. Europe (the colonized countries are indicated in yellow, and the red dots represent the exact locations of observations) and B. Ticino (Switzerland). (Vector and raster map data swisstopo.ch, naturalearthdata.com).
The morphological identification of C. pelliculosum was confirmed by the genetic analysis of two specimens (the sequences were deposited on GenBank: accession numbers OQ872231, OQ872232). According to a fragment of 559 and 577 bp, the BLAST searches confirmed the two sequenced specimens as C. pelliculosum. The nucleotide sequences showed a 99.6% identity to the oxidase subunit I (COI) gene from C. pelliculosum (accession number: GU808702.1).
Hypothenemus eruditus (Westwood, 1834)
Figs
Switzerland • 1 ex.; Stabio; Boschi; 715367, 076920 (45.834090180, 8.923328978); 416 m a.s.l.; 18 May 2022; Sanchez A. leg. and coll. • 3 ex.; Collina d’Oro, Al Lago di Muzzano; 2715063, 1094662 (45.993721864, 8.923739798); 339 m a.s.l.; 16 May–1 Jun. 2022; Sanchez A. coll. and MCSN. • 34 ex.; Locarno, Bolette; 2709941, 1112476 (46.154794646, 8.861816697); 195 m a.s.l.; 2709912, 1112488 (46.154907307, 8.861444194); 195 m a.s.l.; 11 Apr.–14 Jul. 2022; Sanchez A., Knížek M. coll., MCSN and WSL.
Actual known distribution of Hypothenemus eruditus in A. Europe (the colonized countries are indicated in green, and the red dots represent the exact locations of observations) and B. Ticino (Switzerland). (Vector and raster map data swisstopo.ch, naturalearthdata.com).
Despite several attempts on specimens morphologically identified as H. eruditus, genetic analyses yielded no results, probably due to insufficient DNA available in such a small specimen or by the deterioration of the DNA by the trap preservation fluid.
The use of interception traps for saproxylic beetle surveys often allows the detection of cryptic species. This has, for example, enabled the discovery of several rare species in Switzerland (
The important monitoring (using 114 traps) (Fig.
Their ecology, their known distribution in neighbouring countries to date, and the possible threats to the environment associated with their presence are synthesised below.
Cyclorhipidion distinguendum (Fig.
Although its ecology is still poorly known, it seems to preferentially develop on several Fagaceae, Dipterocarpaceae and Pinaceae species, including Castanea sp. and Quercus sp. (
During the summer of 2022, C. distinguendum was regularly caught with traps between the 10th of March and the 10th of October, but more than 70% of the specimens were trapped between April and June. Thus, it seems that their peak activity is in spring. This hypothesis has been corroborated by French occurrences (
Until now, no phytosanitary issues have been reported in relation to C. distinguendum in France or in the United States (
Cyclorhipidion pelliculosum (Fig.
The first specimen discovered in Europe was found on a poplar (Populus sp.) trunk (
Hypothenemus eruditus (Fig.
Originally present in tropical and subtropical regions, it is now sub-cosmopolitan and also present in many temperate regions (
Hypothenemus eruditus is an extremely polyphagous species that develops in small branches, but also in the bark of trunks or branches, in flowers, grasses, seeds, leaf petioles, and twigs (
Due to the variety of substrates in which the species can develop, it is difficult to speculate about how it was introduced into Switzerland. It is highly likely that the species is already naturalized in Switzerland, given that many individuals have been found in three localities several tens of kilometres apart. The European and Mediterranean Plant Protection Organization (EPPO) drew up a non-exhaustive list of means of transport of the species, including their entry with wood (round or sawn, with bark, including firewood), barks, wood chips, hogwood, wood processing residues (except sawdust and shavings), wood packaging material if not treated, processed wood material (e.g., plywood, veneer), plants for planting, or cut branches of host plants (
Despite its highly polyphagous diet, the species does not appear to cause phytosanitary problems in Europe (
These three species were all discovered in Switzerland in 2022, but their already wide known distribution (Figs
These three new species add to the list of alien Scolytinae that are already widely distributed in Switzerland (list of the invasive species provided in the introduction). Even if the majority of these species are now widely distributed in Switzerland, they do not seem to pose any phytosanitary problems for the moment, at least according to our current knowledge, which is often (very) incomplete (
In the last two years, four new alien Scolytinae species (including A. maiche (Ribeiro Correia et al. 2023, Preprint)) have been discovered in Switzerland, and new others will certainly be found in coming years. For example, Xylosandrus compactus (Chapuis & Eichhoff, 1875) is a potential invader. This species was found for the first time in Europe in Italy in 2011 (
The intensive monitoring campaigns carried out in 2022 revealed new alien and potentially invasive species in Switzerland. This shows the importance of such campaigns, especially in Ticino, for quickly detecting the presence of new species in the territory, and thus allowing necessary measures to be taken to eradicate their expansion, if necessary and if possible. Concerning bark and ambrosia beetles, the monitoring campaigns should ideally be conducted in important transit areas of goods, ideally near the borders and in the airports, as is currently done in France and which has allowed the detection of Xyloterinus politus (
We would like to thank Stève Breitenmoser, Heiko Gebhardt and Enrico Ruzzier for their valuable comments on the manuscript. We also thank them, and Benoît Dodelin, for sharing their information on the species and their distribution in different European localities. We are also grateful to Stefano Brignoli, Ivan Candolfi, Lisa Elzi, Giorgio Musso, Lucia Pollini Paltrinieri and Davide Prati for their support during the field work. We finally acknowledge Michel Sartori and Nadir Alvarez for providing us with the photographic equipment. The part of study conducted by Miloš Knížek was supported by the Ministry of Agriculture of the Czech Republic, institutional support MZE-RO0118.